Manchester 0161 832 2500   |   London City 0204 505 8080   |   London Finchley 020 8349 0321

Secure Payment
Logo
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Accreditations
    • Social Responsibility
  • Specialisms
    • All Specialisms
    • Commercial & IP
      • Commercial & Intellectual Property
        • Visit Overview
      • Terms and Conditions of Business
      • Commercial Agreements
      • Intellectual Property
    • Commercial Litigation
      • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
        • Visit Overview
      • Contentious Probate and Trust Solicitors
      • Private Wealth & Trusts Disputes
      • Company & Shareholder Contract Disputes
      • Intellectual Property Dispute Solicitors
      • Insolvency Disputes
      • Injunctions
      • Property Litigation
      • Employment Litigation
      • Professional Negligence
      • Injury & Accident Claims
      • Clinical Negligence
      • Judicial review
    • Corporate
      • Corporate
        • Visit Overview
      • Restructuring and Reorganisation
      • Raising Finance
      • Selling Your Business
      • Joint Ventures
      • Company Advice
      • Management Buy-Outs and Buy-Ins
      • Employee Ownership Trusts (EOTs)
    • Employment
      • Employment
        • Visit Overview
      • Employers
      • Employees
      • HR Professionals
      • In-house Lawyers
      • Entrepreneurs
    • Family
      • Family
        • Visit Overview
      • Divorce, Separation & Dissolution
      • Civil Partnership Dissolution
      • High Net Worth Divorce Solicitors
      • Prenuptial Agreements
      • Post Nuptial Agreements
      • Cohabitation Law Solicitors
      • Mediation Solicitors
      • Collaborative Law Solicitors 
      • One Lawyer Two Clients
      • Arbitration
      • Arrangements for Children
      • International Family Law
      • Domestic Abuse
      • Surrogacy & Fertility
      • Anglo-Swedish Legal Advice
    • Private Client
      • Private Client
        • Visit Overview
      • Wills
      • Grant of Probate
      • Charity Setup
      • Lifetime Gifting
      • Lasting Powers of Attorney
      • Intestacy
      • Insolvent Estates
      • Statutory Wills
      • Trusts
      • Trusts for Children
      • Inheritance
    • Property
      • Property
        • Visit Overview
      • Commercial Conveyancing
      • Commercial Leasing
      • Commercial Property
      • Lease Extensions
      • Property Finance
      • Residential Conveyancing
      • High Net Worth Residential Conveyancing
    • Secured Lending
      • Secured Lending
        • Visit Overview
      • Residential Loans
      • Development Loans
      • Commercial Property Loans
      • Portfolio Loans
      • Overseas Borrowers
      • Bridging Loans
  • Our Team
  • News, Insights & Work
    • News & Insights
    • Case Studies
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
Contact Us
Secured Lending

Mar 2022

Selling property at auction: Amount to disclose

Home | News & Case Studies | Selling property at auction: Amount to disclose

Selling property at auction? How much must you disclose? • BBS Law

Article by Avi Barr – Secured Lending and Property Partner and Head of the London office of BBS Law

Auction sales tend to be a great way of disposing of tricky properties. It may be a shop in prime retail territory with a rapidly weakening tenant covenant or a challenging development site.  You would think that any buyer at an auction ought to know that what you see is not necessarily what you are going to get. However, a recent High Court case has tipped the balance strongly in favour of careless buyers by placing a surprisingly strong responsibility on sellers at auction and auctioneers to ensure that any defects are clearly pointed out to bidders.

The High Court case in SPS Groundworks and Building Ltd v Mahil involved Mr Mahil who purchased a piece of land for £130,000 at auction.  The land had development potential but was subject to overage provisions (additional payments normally to the seller contingent on future events).  The overage deed was included in the pack and the title even had reference to the overage arrangement.  However, Mr Mahil had not downloaded the legal pack and there was no mention within the auction particulars of the overage, nor did the auctioneer make any reference to the overage during the auction itself.  Mr Mahil decided not to complete and was then sued by the seller for his loss.  Although the initial County Court decision came up with what most of us would expect to be the anticipated decision in favour of the seller on the basis of, “caveat emptor”, being the very basic principle that any buyer ought to be aware of what they are buying, the High Court took a different view and actually agreed with Mr Mahil that the initial decision was wrong in law to conclude that the seller had fulfilled its duty to disclose the defect in title by simply including it in the legal pack.

The High Court decision will definitely be a surprise to many but underlines the importance when listing properties for auction (particularly where parties may be bidding unrepresented) to ensure that there is proper disclosure of any defects and its conclusion was that standard contractual conditions and auction disclaimers could not be relied upon to save the seller where a defect in the property was not clearly brought to the attention of prospective buyers.  A purchaser was entitled to assume, in the absence of any clear signposting to the contrary, that entries on the property register were not problematic and that the lot itself was being sold on a standard basis and in this case, the seller had failed to clearly draw sufficient attention to the overage.

For both buyers and sellers, auctions can be minefields and this decision creates even more uncertainty.  How much more did the seller have to do here? Is it necessary to have every defect clearly stated in the catalogue or announced by the auctioneer in the room. In some cases that would defeat the point of selling at auction at all.  If you are a seller, do make sure that you have clearly presented your lot to avoid any claims based on a failure to disclose material issues.  If you are buying at auction, particularly where development may be involved, do ensure that you at the very least download and review the pack and almost always it will be the right thing to do to have a sufficiently skilled solicitor review the pack on your behalf before you enter the bidding.


Share article:

Related Articles


Case Study

Ballingdon Hall: Financing a New Chapter in a Historic Property’s Journey

Read Secured Lending
Insight Heter Iska

Heter Iska: A Comprehensive Guide for Lenders and Borrowers

Read Secured Lending
Podcast

Avi Barr, Head of Secured Lending, Talks Property Finance 🎙️

Read Secured Lending
SCROLL FOR MORE

Sign-up for our newsletter

Name(Required)
Untitled(Required)

Contact Details


Please submit careers applications using the link below

Careers Application: Submit

For proactive, lateral thinking and cost-effective legal advice, contact us to discuss your needs.

Email: [email protected]

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

On the 1st of October 2022, BBS Law acquired OGR Stock Denton Solicitors. OGR Stock Denton were a prominent North London based law firm with more than half a century’s experience assisting individuals and businesses with various legal issues. Many of the solicitors at OGR Stock Denton previously worked in either the West End of London or the City of London. The acquisition of OGR Stock Denton by BBS Law significantly increases the London presence of BBS Law and allows OGR Stock Denton’s clients access to BBS Law’s expert solicitors, previously based solely in Manchester and the City of London and now based at all three locations.


On the 1st of April 2024, BBS Law acquired Manuel Swaden Solicitors. Manuel Swaden were a prominent North West London based law firm known for its expertise in property and private client matters. This strategic move will fortify BBS Law’s position in these areas of practice and enhance its ability to serve clients with excellence and efficiency.

Manchester: 0161 832 2500

Fax: 0161 834 4826

First Floor, The Edge, Clowes Street, Manchester, M3 5NA

Download Directions

London City: 0204 505 8080

Fax: 0161 834 4826

Ground Floor, 80 Coleman Street, London, EC2R 5BJ

Download Directions

London Finchley: 020 8349 0321

Fax: 0161 834 4826

2nd Floor, Winston House, 2 Dollis Park, London, N3 1HF

Download Directions

Logo
  • Careers
  • Compliance
  • Estate Administration Costs
  • Employment Dismissal Costs
  • Debt Recovery Costs
  • Conveyancing Costs
  • Re-mortgaging Costs
  • Complaints Handling Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Staff Area

© 2025 BBS Law Ltd (registered number 07202211) is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority under Number 556112. London City office SRA authority no: 8008216. London Finchley office SRA authority no: 8002172.
Managed by Full Send.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkDeny